top of page

Russian Minorca

12 hours ago
8 min read

By Gary Oswald.


An 1803 map of the Harbour of Mahon (Mahón, or Maó in Catalan) by Thomas Walsh. Britain had just lost it to the Spanish - could it instead have been a map of Russian gains? Image public domain, courtesy Wikimedia Commons.
An 1803 map of the Harbour of Mahon (Mahón, or Maó in Catalan) by Thomas Walsh. Britain had just lost it to the Spanish - could it instead have been a map of Russian gains? Image public domain, courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Great Britain left the Seven Years War of 1756–1763 in an incredibly strong position, with their Empire having conquered a great deal of land from their rivals of France and Spain, from colonies in North America and West Africa to the Spanish land of Gibraltar and Minorca. However, not only were Spain and France both keen on revenge, all of Britain’s European allies resented it for prioritising British territorial gains in the peace treaties.


The result of all this was when the Thirteen Colonies rebelled in 1775, Britain was diplomatically isolated. France joined the war on the side of the rebels in 1778, Spain declared war on the Brits in 1779, and any possible allies who could open a second front in Europe to distract France and Spain remained neutral. In fact, in 1780 their old allies formed the League of Armed Neutrality alongside other states like Russia. The League claimed the right to trade openly with both sides of the war and to declare war against anyone attempting to blockade or search their shipping, something aimed primarily at the British who were the greater naval power.


In 1780, Britain declared war on the Dutch before they could join the League, with the aim of disrupting Dutch trade to the Franco-Spanish alliance. Also in that year, the powerful Indian Kingdom of Mysore invaded British India, which was racked with anti-British revolts. So now Great Britain was at war with the American rebels, Spain, France, the Netherlands and Mysore, and soon began losing on every front. Crucially for this article, Minorca was recaptured in 1782 and returned to Spain. The fact Gibraltar was besieged for nearly four years but held out was one of the few major British victories of the wars, otherwise their worst defeat since the Union of the Crowns. These losses meant this time, the peace agreements were not in Britain’s favour.


Britain could have fared still worse, of course. France and Spain agreed to a peace in 1783 due to the cost of the war rather than taking advantage of their victories to fight until they had won more territory back. Given their diplomatic isolation, Britain's losses, though one fifth of the population of the British Empire at that time, were a decent outcome for Great Britain. This was not the British opinion at the time, obviously; George III drafted an abdication notice in 1781, a thing that was unheard of, such was his concept of his own failure. However, in hindsight the loss was less damaging than it originally appeared. After all, Britain kept hold of both most of their sugar islands and their land in India, which gave them the economic base that would allow them to conquer all of India and form the largest empire known to man.


What is clear, both in hindsight and at the time, is that the easiest path for a British victory is for a powerful European ally to join on the British side. And the obvious choice was Russia.


British diplomacy from 1775 to 1780 focused increasingly on getting Catherine the Great's expanding Russian Empire to act as a counterweight to force France or Spain to back down. They offered her huge amounts of money for either a Russian declaration of war or at least Russian soldiers and ships being allowed to join the British forces as mercenaries. However, while Catherine was interested she ultimately turned them down due to worries that she wouldn't be able to sell Russian involvement in a war in America to her own government without provoking a coup against her and so instead was a founder member of the League of Armed Neutrality.


The idea of Catherine deciding to go ahead with that alliance instead is the subject of this article which focuses on the consequences of a British North America in which the rebels lose and thousands of Russian soldiers arrive there. But the effects of it on Russia are equally interesting. For a start, maybe that coup Catherine was worried about does happen. Anti-Catherine elements in St. Petersburg were about to publish that she was going to drag them into a war with France and Spain, when she got ahead of the story by going public with the negotiations and rejecting them. If instead she had agreed this alliance, maybe those elements succeed in damaging her reputation and encouraging her removal, in the same way her husband had been removed. An early removal of Catherine the Great, prior to her wars against Poland, Sweden, Persia and the Ottoman Empire, changes the history of Russia and Europe hugely.


But in terms of Catherine selling joining the British side to her aristocracy, she did have a way of justifying the war that perhaps would have shored up her position.


The British admiralty seems to have given up on being able to hold on to Minorca by the time Spain declared war in June 1779. As a result, in late 1779 the British Ambassador to Russia (James Harris) made the suggestion to Lord North's government that they offer Minorca to Russia while they still held it because they'd rather lose territory to their friends than their enemies and Lord North's government gave him permission to make the offer around early 1780. What exactly the British wanted in return is unclear, Lord Stormont claimed merely to want Catherine's goodwill if her ceasefire plan to come into action and she acted as a mediator between the sides, but some Russian sources suggest it was part of yet another plea for Russia to join the war on Britain's side (in particular that Harris wanted Catherine to threaten France into a separate peace).


In any case, as stated, Catherine made the offer public to get ahead of her enemies, Britain was humiliated and backed away from the offer, and Catherine then declared the League of Armed Neutrality to Britain's outrage. Minorca was invaded by the Spanish a year later.


But according to Harris (who admittedly obviously has an agenda here given how humiliating to him personally the scheme's failure was) the Russians were interested in purchasing Minorca. He said in 1782:


'Why this project failed I am still at a loss to learn. I never knew the Empress incline so strongly to any one measure as she did to this, before I had my full powers to treat, nor was I ever more astonished than when I found her shrink from her purpose when they arrived. I imputed it at the same time, in my own mind, to the rooted aversion she had for our Ministry, and her total want of confidence in them; but I since am more strongly disposed to believe that she consulted the Emperor (of Austria) on the subject, and that he not only prevailed on her to decline the offer, but betrayed the secret to France, and that it thus became public. I cannot otherwise account for this rapid change of sentiment in the Empress, particularly as Prince Potemkin (whatever he might be in other transactions) was certainly in this cordial and sincere in his support, and both from what I saw at the time, and from what has since come to my knowledge, had its success at heart as much as myself.'


Harris is perhaps blaming Austrian interference on what was actually internal Russian opposition but there is something compelling here. For a start, it feels like a farce. The UK giving territory to Russia rather than lose them to war is an Asterix joke which ends with all of the Russian empire owned by Britain and all of the British Empire by Russia.


But let's just assume Catherine does go through with the nominal purchase of Minorca before the French and Spanish invade it. At this point Russia has ports in the Black and Baltic seas but it has no chance of holding Minorca by force, or even getting enough troops there to do the handover that quickly, and the Spanish probably refuse to recognise the sale as they'd argue Britain had no right to sell it.


If you are Catherine the Great and you are trying to justify a very profitable deal with the British Empire that you know is unpopular because it involves Russian soldiers dying for no benefit to Russia… an invasion of Russian land is a way to do that.


So the deal is announced in 1780. France and Spain, planning an invasion of Minorca, are stymied. Do they go ahead with the invasion or not?


We can sketch out a few scenarios here.


France and Spain do invade but the Russian internal reaction is indifference, as it is territory that has never really been theirs, and so Russia backs down and this tarnishes Catherine’s aura and encourages her enemies.


France and Spain protest but allow the handover to happen and Catherine simply agrees to sell her new territory to Spain in return for concessions in Alaska and California, where the countries were in dispute, and moves on. Spain gain back Minorca peacefully and have more troops to send to Gibraltar, Russia get one over on Great Britain, the League of Armed Neutrality is still formed, and the war goes basically the same.


France and Spain back down and allow the sale to go through, giving Russia an island in the Mediterranean but no excuse to join the British side of the war, meaning they still remain neutral. At which point Britain, feeling betrayed, maybe withdraws the offer and so the invasion still happens and Russia-British relations are at all time a low.


Or the invasion happens, Russia is outraged, and the scheme works, completely changing the complexion of the war. Britain might still lose but less so, or they might actually win thanks to Russian manpower.


An interesting consequence might be if France was fine with Russia holding Minorca but Spain wasn't and goes ahead with the invasion against French wishes, which, depending on the result, could lead to increasing tension between the two sides.


A Russian Minorca, however you get there, is an interesting setting for a story anyway. It’s going to be attacked by the Corsairs of Algiers every time Russia fights the Ottoman Empire for a start. Likewise, it is going to be a battleground between Revolutionary France and the Coalitions during those wars if they still happen, with any Napoleonic figure who might arise likely capturing it. And if it survives to an equivalent of the Russian Revolution, it could be a Taiwan parallel as a White Russian state in exile.


But let’s talk about the people of Minorca at the time, most of whom are probably not going to be thrilled about becoming Russian. The majority, around 30,000, were Catalan Catholics who are probably going to revolt upon being handed to a Slavic Orthodox Empire. But there were around 600 non-Catalans who had arrived during British rule and who the Spanish immediately exiled upon capturing Minorca. About a hundred of them were Jews and about five hundred were Greeks. This gives a base of people who probably would prefer a Russian ruler to a Spanish one.


And we know that during British rule, the Greeks actively lobbying to bring more of their people there from Ottoman-ruled Greece. There was also a Greek population in Genoan-ruled Corsica who found their village repeatedly attacked by the Corsicans and would end up fleeing to Algeria. An island under Orthodox rule might well see a Greek influx of immigrants which would change the character of the Island, though that would be likely be stunningly unpopular with the native Catalans. Even if Minorca ends up being returned to Spain later by a Russian monarch who thinks it’s not worth the hassle to keep, this might have a huge effect on the island’s character.


It certainly has an effect on Russian-Greek relations during and after any Greek War of Independence. Russia supported Greek rebels on numerous occasions and Catherine the Great had openly proposed the creation of a Greek puppet state out of the Ottoman Empire. Strategically a Russian island in the Western Mediterranean gives Moscow the opportunity to attack Istanbul from both sides and a stronger motive for wanting access through the Bosporus Strait, but it also gives Russia something to lose if a Greek state is created and the Minorcan Greeks have somewhere else to go.


It is fascinating that a tiny Island so far from Russia could have had such a big role in Russian strategy that it might have been the difference between neutrality and an Anglo-Russian Alliance.



Gary Oswald is the editor of the Grapeshot and Guillotines, Emerald Isles, and If We'd Just Got That Penalty anthologies.


Comments


© 2025, Sea Lion Press

  • Facebook
  • gfds_edited_edited
bottom of page